Friday, 22 November 2024

Joining the Matchbox Challenge (Part 1)

Two wargaming blogs I enjoy following, Man of Tin and The Duchy of Tradgardland, have been discussing a design challenge to create a wargame that fits inside a standard matchbox. This concept interested their readers and they have opened the challenge to anyone, with more details available here. The concept of making a wargame compact enough to fit into a standard matchbox intrigues me, so I have decided to give it a try. Over the past week, I’ve been pondering ideas for the challenge while also making progress on painting my house (and I am happy to report it's now halfway done! The house that is, not my pondering.)

A 30mm long ironclad model steaming along.

Not having any of my wargaming and modelling equipment available means I cannot reuse any models, for example, a handful of 15mm figures for a skirmish game. So I decided I would have to create some models for the challenge, while not fully ruling out land games, this has pushed me in the direction of naval and air wargame ideas. Both have the advantage of not really having to include any terrain features into the game, any features required would take up valuable space in the matchbox. The matchbox’s dimensions (34mm x 55mm x 14mm) set the size constraints for the project. 

In the end I decided on a naval-themed game. The American Civil War riverine battles with ironclads seemed like a good choice because their blocky designs should be easier to make using materials like card, toothpicks, and Milliput epoxy putty. 

Four prototype ships have been built to fit within the matchbox and still leave room for a single D6 die, each ship is 30mm long. Having four ships will allow for a variety of scenarios such as one-versus-three escapes, late arrival of reinforcements, or straightforward one-on-one duels.

The half finished models in the matchbox with a small die.

The models are complete and just need a bit of sanding before being painted in a mix of dark grey and brown.

The next steps in this challenge for me, aside from finishing the models, are:

  1. Create some riverbanks and sandbanks using string, which can be coiled to fit inside the matchbox.
  2. Write some simple rules that fit on a small sheet of paper to fit into the matchbox (around half the size of A4 or Letter paper) or that can be cut up and pasted onto the outside of the matchbox.
  3. Design ship cards for each vessel, including their details and stats to support the rules.
The next post on this challenge will be about the rules where I plan to use the matchbox as a measuring tool for movement and ranges.


    29 comments:

    1. I have followed this challenge on various blogs, great idea from Allan and interesting to see what people come up with, your idea is a cracker, really well thought out and done, hard to think you could get a game in a matchbox but you can!! Looking forward to your next post on the rules. Superb start that's for sure.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Keeping the rules short and succinct will be the challenge. I have limited access to a printer so they will also have to be hand-written. Such an clever challenge from Alan and Man of Tin.

        Delete
    2. What a splendid start!
      Alan Tradgardland

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Thank you. I am really enjoying the challenge you thought up.

        Delete
    3. Wouldn't have thought it possible- but you've done it- excellent idea for the Matchbox- great little ship models as well- good work indeed.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. It is quite surprising how much can be fitted into a matchbox. Thanks.

        Delete
    4. Impressive! The whole package, rules and all, inside one matchbox! I do like those wee warships, too!
      Cheers,
      Ion

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Thanks Ion. Modelling the ships was great fun, it seems ages since I have made or painted any models.

        Delete
    5. Looking great, Peter! I am very much looking forward to seeing the rules and the game in action.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. I am hoping I can get the rules drafted next week. Then there will be the challenge of getting them to fit in the matchbox.

        Delete
    6. I love ironclads

      Please print a set of rules

      Just bought the Osprey European ironclad book

      Pete

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. I will certainly be writing the rules up on the blog.

        Delete
    7. They look good Peter. Puts me in mind of the model ships ('fleets') in Diplomacy. Mmmmm!

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Thanks. I was also thinking of the old Monopoly battleship playing piece.

        Delete
    8. You are off to a very good start! Great looking ships!

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Yes, a good start. Now to paint the models. I bought the paint, but forgot to buy a brush.

        Delete
    9. Interesting to see how this all plays out, you even have room for some shell splashes (flat drawing pins with a bit of putty on the pin) to keep track of damage. How big is the matchbox?

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. The matchbox’s dimensions are 34mm x 55mm x 14mm. I like the suggestion of splashes.

        Delete
      2. An alternative record keeping method would be to punch rows of holes (one for each ship) in the bottom of the ‘drawer’ and use some sort of pegs to record damage (mini-mastermind pegs are ideal for this sort of thing).

        Delete
      3. A clever idea. At the moment the ‘drawer’ is being used for measuring, but I will store that idea away if things change.

        Delete
    10. Very clever ideas Peter and I look forward to the final result.
      I will check out the two blogs you mentioned.

      ReplyDelete
    11. I was always the monopoly dreadnought

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. Likewise, or if the dreadnought was taken it was the racing car.

        Delete
    12. Very innovative, Peter, and the idea of gluing the rules onto the matchbox’s outer surface stands out as a fine way to overcome the limitations that the challenge imposes.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. At the moment I plan to have the combat and movement tables stuck to the outside to save space.

        Delete
    13. Superb idea Peter. Your creativity and ingenuity never cease to amaze me. I look forward to the evolution of this challenge.

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. I am looking froward to working my way through this wonderful challenge of Alan and Man of Tin.

        Delete
    14. You’re a clever devil Peter. Top stuff. Watching with interest!

      ReplyDelete
      Replies
      1. I am sure there will be a couple more posts as I progress with this challenge.

        Delete