This week I hosted a remote Samurai wargame with Jon of the Palouse Wargaming Journal. The game was loosely based on the Second Battle of Azukizaka, fought in 1548, with the Command & Colors Samurai Battle website providing details of the battle.
We have wargamed this battle before a couple of years ago when Jon had previously hosted, using a slightly modified version of the Basic Impetus rules.
 |
| A close up of Jon's forces and command tent. |
For the game, I used the wargame rules Arrowstorm by Daniel Mersey. Although designed for medieval games, I have found the rules seem to work well for my Samurai games (see my earlier battle report for the Battle of Nagakute, 1584).
I have added a few house rules for the Sengoku period. The main change being the tactical unit of a Sonae is treated as a single formation consisting of Teppo (arquebus), ashigaru and samurai. These three elements operate together and must remain grouped throughout the game.
The main (and interesting) feature of the Arrowstorm rules is the Command Chart where players alternatively place up to four orders markers on the shared Commands Chart. There are four order markers, which can be reduced by 1 for every 3 Sonae lost, or if a general leaves their command tent to join a Sonae and boost its strength.
 |
| The command chart with orders placed. The orders tokens are samurai messengers that get placed on the tabletop as they are used during a game turn. |
One of the advantages of Arrowstorm rules is that they use a gridded tabletop, which is very helpful for remote gaming as it removes the uncertainty around movement and combat ranges for the remote player.
Background
The Second Battle of Azukizaka, took place in 1548 between the forces of the Imagawa clan, commanded by Imagawa Yoshimoto's general, Taigen Sessai, and the Oda clan, led by Oda Nobuhide.
The Armies
For this scenario, both sides have an identical force structure, consisting of:
- Five Sonae.
- One command tent.
Deployment
 |
| Imagawa are in red and Oda in blue. |
 |
| The tabletop setup. You can just make out the hexes which are marked on their corners. Jon said these are very clearer on the camera showing the game remotely. I use my iPhone on a tripod for this. |
Jon opted to play the Imagawa army which are in red and I the Oda army in blue. All my samurai figures are painted as either a generic blue and grey or red and brown. There is no historical accuracy to actual clan colours or Mon (emblems).
Game report
The Imagawa army began with the initiative and quickly moved a couple of Sonae into position on the hills along Oda's right flank. After an initial clash with the advancing Oda forces, one Oda Sonae was routed and another opted to fall back and rally after taking a number of hits. Having won the opening round of combat, the Imagawa forces pressed forward, looking to exploit their early advantage.
A lone Oda Sonae held its ground in the centre while other Sonae were hurried forward to support it.
 |
| The Imagawa forces appear on the hills. |
 |
| Imagawa forces pressed forward, looking to exploit their early advantage, as a lone Oda Sonae holds the centre |
For a moment, it looked as though the Imagawa may have overextended themselves and were becoming outnumbered in the centre as more Oda Sonae arrived. However, any opportunity for the Oda to take advantage of this situation was squandered by some rather ineffective shooting from their Teppo (6 dice rolls and not one hit! I assume the powder was damp). The Imagawa troops quickly recovered, bringing more Sonae into the centre, as the fighting soon developed into one rather large melee.
 |
| Imagawa look to have overextended themselves and are becoming outnumbered in the centre. |
 |
| A large melee develops in the centre as both armies rush forward troops. |
The Oda army did enjoy a brief change in fortunes, managing to rout one of the Imagawa Sonae in the centre. Their general had left the command tent to join the fighting, providing an additional boost to his troops. Unfortunately, this success was short-lived. More Imagawa Sonae joined the battle on the flanks, allowing them to regain the initiative and rout a second Oda Sonae.
The Oda forces were now firmly on the back foot. Before long, another Sonae was lost, along with their general killed in the fighting. This proved to be a decisive blow, handing victory to the Imagawa army.
 |
| Imagawa forces join the fighting in the centre, routing an Oda Sonae and regaining the initiative. |
 |
| The Oda army is on the back foot and would soon begin to rout and lose their general. |
Wrap up
A most enjoyable game, and well played to Jon on his victory! There was a brief moment about halfway through the battle when I thought I might be able to gain the upper hand in the centre, but it proved to be elusive. Jon was able to steadily whittle down my forces and secure a victory.
In the game I particularly liked having the Sonae represented as combined-arms formations. The orders and command chart are an important part of the rules and add an extra twist to the game. With all the Sonae being essentially the same, the choice of orders provides some interesting decisions and helps distinguish how the formations are used during the battle.
After the game, Jon and I had a look through the command chart to see which of the special orders we had either overlooked or simply forgotten to use. One that had escaped my attention was Personal Challenge. This order allows samurai within a Sonae to issue a personal challenge which, if successful, delays all attacks against that Sonae until the following turn. This may have been useful, but likely would only have delayed my loss. However, I will certainly need to remind myself of some of these special orders before our next game.
If I decide to stick with these rules (which I think I might - famous last words) I am wondering whether to rebase the figures onto a single base for each Sonae. Where teppo, ashigaru, and samurai on foot and mounted would all be combined together on one base. For my Sonae house rules it would be very practical, as I would easily get two bases into one hex as required by the rules. Aesthetically it would also look very nice, but I would not want to change my mind!
No comments:
Post a Comment